| Year | Name | College |
|---|---|---|
| 1863 | Walter Bradford Woodgate | Brasenose |
| 1863 | C Ellis | Merton |
| 1864 | C W Spencer Stancote | Merton |
| 1865 | J H Forster | University |
| 1865 | Edward Carr Glyn | University |
| 1866 | W H P Leukais | Merton |
| 1866 | Albert Brasery | University |
| 1867 | Lawrence | Balliol |
| 1868 | W Wightesman Wood | University |
| 1868 | Edward L Fellowes | Brasenose |
| 1869 | S H Woodhouse | University |
| 1870 | J C Tinne | University |
| 1871 | C S Newton | University |
| 1872 | Robert Lesley | Pembroke |
| 1872 | L Townshend | Brasenose |
| 1873 | E S Garnier | University |
| 1874 | M G Farrer | Brasenose |
| 1875 | W Walter Whitmore | Brasenose |
| 1876 | J G Bankes | University |
| 1876 | Chesterfield | Brasenose |
| 1877 | T C Edwards-Moss | Brasenose |
| 1878 | Audley C Miles | Brasenose |
| 1879 | W H Moss | University |
| 1879 | W H Stanfell | Balliol |
| 1880 | G D Rowe | University |
| 1881 | A H Evans | Oriel |
| 1881 | M Lubbock | Balliol |
| 1882 | W Oliver | University |
| 1882 | Brimsley FitzGerald | University |
| 1883 | A R Paterson | Trinity |
| 1884 | M C Kemp | Hertford |
| 1885 | A G Elisher | Brasenose |
| 1885 | L Owen | New |
| 1886 | D H McLean | New |
| 1886 | H T A Thompson | Brasenose |
| 1887 | G W Ricketts | Oriel |
| 1887 | H H Castens | Brasenose |
| 1888 | H R Racken | Brasenose |
| 1889 | H Philips | New |
| 1890 | Guy Nickalls | Magdalen |
| 1891 | F Thesiger | Magdalen |
| 1892 | Edward Murray | Oriel |
| 1893 | G Combe | Magdalen |
| 1894 | Hugh B Cotton | Magdalen |
| 1895 | W Burton Stewart | Brasenose |
| 1896 | Henry D G Leveson-Gower | Magdalen |
| 1897 | E R Balfour | University |
| 1898 | C K Philips | New |
| 1899 | Thomas A Nelson | University |
| 1900 | R G Foster | University |
| 1901 | Felix W Warre | Balliol |
| 1902 | Horace J Hale | Balliol |
| 1903 | W Findlay | Oriel |
| 1904 | E G M-Williams | University |
| 1905 | A K Graham | Balliol |
| 1906 | K Cornwallis | University |
| 1907 | Patrick Munro | Christ Church |
| 1908 | E L Wright | New |
| 1909 | A G Kirby | Magdalen |
| 1910 | H Bonsey | University |
| 1911 | G Cunningham | Magdalen |
| 1912 | R O Lagden | Oriel |
| 1913 | Roy Bardsley | Merton |
| 1914 | D M Bairn | Trinity |
| 1915 | H. le B. Lightfoot (Snr Treasurer) | Corpus Christi |
| 1916 | “ | “ |
| 1917 | “ | “ |
| 1918 | “ | “ |
| 1919 | Edward D Horsfall | Magdalen |
| 1920 | Miles Howell | Oriel |
| 1921 | Bevil G D’U Rudd | Trinity |
| 1922 | V R Price | Magdalen |
| 1923 | W R Milligan | University |
| 1924 | R J Denison | Oriel |
| 1925 | H J Kittermaster | University |
| 1926 | Dunglass | Christ Church |
| 1927 | G E B Abell | Corpus Christi |
| 1928 | Charles Frazer | Balliol |
| 1929 | D A Nunn | New |
| 1930 | A T Barber | Queen’s |
| 1931 | J S M Paul | St John’s |
| 1932 | P G V van der Bijl | Brasenose |
| 1933 | Alan McWillis | Trinity |
| 1934 | J E Lovelock | Exeter |
| 1935 | Michael Mosley | Trinity |
| 1936 | John W Seamer | Brasenose |
| 1937 | Roger Pulbrook | Magdalen |
| 1938 | Alan Pennington | Hertford |
| 1939 | F M M Forster | Trinity |
| 1940 | J C Lawrie (Hon Sec) | Brasenose |
| 1941 | R C H Risley (Hon Sec) | Oriel |
| 1942 | E K Scott (Hon Sec) | Lincoln |
| 1943 | W J H Butterfield (Hon Sec) | Exeter |
| 1944 | D A B Garton-Sprenger (Hon Sec) | Merton |
| 1945 | J B Dossetor (Hon Sec) | St John’s |
| 1946 | David Macindoe MC | Christ Church |
| 1947 | David G Jamison | Magdalen |
| 1948 | J O Newton-Thompson | Trinity |
| 1949 | G P Jackson | Brasenose |
| 1950 | Roger G Bannister | Exeter |
| 1951 | D B Carr | Worcester |
| 1952 | P D S Blake | Brasenose |
| 1953 | C S Cheshire | Trinity |
| 1954 | R K Pitamber | St Edmund Hall |
| 1955 | D C P R Jowett | St John’s |
| 1955 | Roy C P Allaway | University |
| 1956 | M J K Smith | St Edmund Hall |
| 1957 | D J N Johnson | Lincoln |
| 1958 | Robin H Davies | New |
| 1959 | Mike A Eagar | Worcester |
| 1960 | A W N Gemmill | Brasenose |
| 1961 | F E Robin Butler | University |
| 1962 | I L Elliott | Keble |
| 1963 | J J McPartlin | St Edmund Hall |
| 1964 | C J G Atkinson | St Edmund Hall |
| 1965 | J M W Hogan | Trinity |
| 1966 | M R J Guest | Magdalen |
| 1967 | R M Oliver | St Edmund Hall |
| 1968 | G N S Ridley | Pembroke |
| 1969 | R H Phillips | Corpus Christi |
| 1969 | F S Goldstein | St Edmund Hall |
| 1970 | J L Corbett | St Peter’s |
| 1971 | P R Carroll | Mansfield |
| 1972 | G B Stevenson | University |
| 1973 | C B Hamblin | Keble |
| 1974/5 | J W Lee | Christ Church |
| 1975/6 | P N A Quinnen | Wadham |
| 1977 | R I Eddington | Lincoln |
| 1978 | P B Fisher | Christ Church |
| 1979 | J G M Webster | Oriel |
| 1980 | R B Clark | Christ Church |
| 1981 | J J Rogers | University |
| 1982 | R Marsden | Christ Church |
| 1983 | A H Hobart | Exeter |
| 1984 | P B Mbu | St Edmund Hall |
| 1985 | A J T Miller | St Edmund Hall |
| 1986 | C S Horner | Worcester |
| 1987 | J M Risman | St Edmund Hall |
| 1988 | M Lawson-Statham | University |
| 1989 | D J Bucknall | St Peter’s |
| 1990 | R J Horrocks-Taylor | St Peter’s |
| 1991 | M Merrick | Christ Church |
| 1992 | S Sparrow | St Edmund Hall |
| 1993 | J R Elliot | St Anne’s |
| 1994 | T Watson | St Edmund Hall |
| 1995 | A N S Bryce | St Edmund Hall |
| 1996 | A D O’Mahony | St Anne’s |
| 1997 | A T Roberts-Miller | Worcester |
| 1998 | T G A Griffiths | Keble |
| 1999 | J P Willcocks | Brasenose |
| 2000 | T A Doyle | St Edmund Hall |
| 2001 | R G Woodfine | St Edmund Hall |
| 2002 | T O R Perry | St Edmund Hall |
| 2003 | J J Fulford | – |
| 2004 | C T T Edwards | Balliol |
| 2005 | D G Hughes | Jesus |
| 2006 | J P E Boto | University |
| 2007 | D N Abbott | Somerville |
| 2008 | R W H Payne | St Peter’s |
| 2009 | T D Smith | Worcester |
| 2010 | H A McCormick | Lincoln |
| 2011 | A J Healy | Worcester |
| 2012 | J A Pearson-Stuttard | Christ Church |
| 2013 | B R Mansfield | Oriel |
| 2014 | M A Neil | St Hilda’s |
| 2015 | S Westaway | Green Templeton |
| 2016 | A McCunn | New |
| 2017 | M Shorthose | University |
| 2018 | R Llyr | Green Templeton |
| 2019 | S Taylor | St Catherine’s |